1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Understanding Surcharge Fees in New York

Understanding Surcharge Fees in New York

February 25, 2025

Introduction

In recent years, the landscape of credit card surcharging in New York has undergone significant changes, particularly with the introduction of new laws aimed at enhancing transparency and consumer protection. This report delves into the specifics of New York's credit card surcharge laws, effective February 11, 2024, and their implications for both consumers and merchants. By examining the legal framework, compliance requirements, and the potential impact on businesses and consumers, this report aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of surcharge fees in New York.

Legal Framework for Credit Card Surcharging in New York

Historically, New York had a ban on credit card surcharges, which was challenged in the courts. In 2017, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that this ban violated the First Amendment, prompting the state to reconsider its stance on surcharging. As a result, in December 2023, Governor Kathy Hochul signed legislation that repealed the no-surcharge law and established a new framework for how surcharges can be applied.

Key Provisions of the New Law

The new law, codified under New York General Business Law § 518, outlines several critical provisions that merchants must adhere to when imposing surcharges on credit card transactions:

  1. Surcharge Limitations: Merchants are restricted from charging a surcharge that exceeds the amount charged to them by the credit card company for processing the transaction. This means that if a merchant incurs a processing fee of 2.5% for a credit card transaction, they cannot impose a surcharge greater than that amount.

  2. Total Price Disclosure: Before checkout, businesses must clearly and conspicuously display the total price of an item or service, inclusive of the surcharge. This requirement aims to prevent hidden fees and ensure that consumers are aware of the final cost before completing their purchase.

  3. Two-Tier Pricing System: Merchants are permitted to adopt a two-tier pricing system, where they display both the cash price and the credit card price (inclusive of the surcharge). This system allows consumers to make informed choices about their payment methods.

  4. Penalties for Non-Compliance: Businesses that fail to comply with these regulations may face civil penalties of up to $500 for each violation. Enforcement can be carried out by local consumer affairs offices or the New York Attorney General's office.

Exclusions from the Law

It is important to note that the new surcharge law does not apply to debit card transactions. This distinction means that merchants are not allowed to impose surcharges on debit card payments, which can lead to confusion among consumers who may not be aware of this difference.

Compliance Requirements for Merchants

To ensure compliance with the new laws, merchants must take several steps:

  1. Clear Communication: Merchants must inform customers about the surcharge before the transaction is completed. This can be achieved through signage at the point of sale and on the checkout page for online transactions.

  2. Training Staff: Employees should be trained to explain the surcharge policy to customers, ensuring that they can answer any questions and provide clarity about the pricing structure.

  3. Regular Audits: Businesses should conduct regular audits of their pricing practices to ensure compliance with the law and avoid potential penalties.

  4. Documentation: Keeping detailed records of all transactions and surcharges applied can help businesses defend against any claims of non-compliance.

Impact on Businesses

The introduction of surcharge fees can have mixed implications for businesses. On one hand, surcharging allows merchants to recoup some of the costs associated with credit card processing, which can be particularly beneficial for small businesses facing tight margins. According to industry estimates, credit card processing fees can range from 1.5% to 3.5% of the transaction amount.

However, businesses must also consider the potential backlash from consumers. A survey indicated that approximately 71% of consumers avoid businesses that impose surcharge fees, suggesting that while surcharging may alleviate some financial burdens, it could also deter customers and impact sales.

Best Practices for Implementation

To mitigate the negative impact of surcharging, businesses may consider the following best practices:

  1. Transparency: Clearly communicate the reasons for the surcharge to customers, emphasizing that it is a necessary measure to cover processing costs.

  2. Cash Discounts: Instead of imposing a surcharge, businesses could offer a discount for cash payments. This approach can be more palatable for consumers and may encourage cash transactions.

  3. Customer Feedback: Actively seek customer feedback regarding the surcharge policy and be willing to adjust practices based on consumer sentiment.

Consumer Protection and Rights

The new surcharge law aims to enhance consumer protection by ensuring that customers are fully informed about the costs associated with their payment methods. Consumers have the right to know the total price they will pay, including any surcharges, before completing a transaction.

Reporting Violations

Consumers who believe they have been charged an improper surcharge can file complaints with the New York State Department of State Division of Consumer Protection or the Attorney General's office. This mechanism provides a means for consumers to seek redress and hold businesses accountable for non-compliance.

Conclusion

The implementation of New York's credit card surcharge laws marks a significant shift in how businesses can manage credit card processing fees. While surcharging can provide financial relief to merchants, it also requires careful consideration of consumer perceptions and compliance with legal requirements. By prioritizing transparency and adhering to the regulations set forth in the law, businesses can navigate this new landscape effectively while maintaining customer trust.

As New York continues to adapt to the changing dynamics of payment processing, both merchants and consumers must stay informed about their rights and responsibilities under the new laws. The ongoing dialogue between businesses and consumers will be crucial in shaping the future of credit card surcharging in the state.

References

Read more:
How to Obtain a Junior Driver's License in New York February 1, 2025 Introduction Obtaining a junior driver's license in New York is a significant milestone for many teenagers, marking the transition from a learner's p... Read more
Step-by-Step Guide to Obtaining a Commercial Driver's License (CDL) in NYC February 17, 2025 Obtaining a Commercial Driver's License (CDL) in New York City (NYC) is a structured process that requires prospective drivers to fulfill specific re... Read more
Passing Your New York State Road Test: A Comprehensive Guide March 13, 2025 Obtaining a driver's license is a significant milestone in an individual's life, symbolizing independence and responsibility. In New York State, the ... Read more
Understanding Aggravated DWI Charges in New York February 28, 2025 Introduction Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) is a serious offense in New York State, with stringent laws and penalties in place to deter impaired dri... Read more